Changelog
Every data update, correction, and methodology change is logged here and in each clinic's own change history. The rating updates whenever the underlying public data changes.
| Date | Subject | Change |
|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-09 | Cabinet des Drs Damiani et Richelme | Manual red flag aggressive_marketing (low) set at gate E2: the clinic publishes 4.94/84 in its own schema.org markup against a live Google record of 4.4/30 (phase-I browser pass, 2026-09-08). Wave-4 precedent for an unverifiable superlative claim published by the clinic itself (e-decisions §1.4 / §9 #5). cabinet-dentaire-mc2l-marseille, whose self-published 4.8/8 sits 0.3 above a live 4.5, is deliberately not flagged — a gap that small on a base of eight is staleness, not a claim. |
| 2026-09-09 | The Madeleine Dental Practice | Duplicate card removed at gate E2 (wave 5). "la-smile-clinic" was a second card for this same practice — identical address (8 Boulevard de la Madeleine), telephone (+33 1 40 70 95 64), website (cabinet-dentaire-madeleine.com), WhatsApp number and Google place (feature id 0x47e66f221a265161:0xcedf57c474fda192) — and both cards carried the same measured reputation figures after the phase-I browser pass. The clinic’s own home page settles which brand is current: "La Smile Clinic Paris devient le Cabinet Dentaire de la Madeleine", and its Business Profile is titled "Le Cabinet Dentaire de la Madeleine | Paris". This card is kept under the current brand and already discloses the former one; merged into <this card>, same address/phone/site/place. No data was lost: the two cards were field-identical. |
| 2026-09-08 | 62LTM / Dr Karim Dada | Reputation measured live on 2026-09-08 by the wave-5 phase-I browser pass (agent I-1), which opened this clinic’s Google Maps place page in a real browser on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. This card enters the country directory as a twin and carries no entry in data/research/*.json, so import-research.js never touched it and respondsToReviews, recurringComplaints and suspiciousReviewPatterns had never been assessed at all. Written now: googleRating 5.0 → 5.0 (unchanged, re-verified); googleReviewCount 70 → 71 (histogram 70/1/0/0/0 = 71, weighted mean 4.986); reviewRecency within_year (unchanged, now proved); respondsToReviews null → false; recurringComplaints null → false; suspiciousReviewPatterns null → false; realClinicPhotos null → true; convenientHours null → false. The histogram sums to the place-page header count exactly and its weighted mean reproduces the published rating to one decimal. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. The country twin was re-synchronised from this card in the same step; the two copies are identical except for the twin’s city key. |
| 2026-09-08 | Arenas Dentistes | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count (previously unknown — the headless map method never returns it), the histogram itself (190/8/1/0/9 = 208, weighted mean 4.779), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the eight most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-08 | Cabinet 47VH | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count (previously unknown — the headless map method never returns it), the histogram itself (5/0/0/0/0 = 5, weighted mean 5.000), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the five most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-08 | Cabinet Dentaire d'Ainay | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count (previously unknown — the headless map method never returns it), the histogram itself (233/4/3/2/38 = 280, weighted mean 4.400), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the eight most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-08 | Cabinet Dentaire Dr Charbit & Associés | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count, the histogram itself (45/0/0/0/0 = 45, weighted mean 5.000), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the eight most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-08 | Cabinet dentaire du Dr Mailhes et Dr Sabatie | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count (previously unknown — the headless map method never returns it), the histogram itself (28/1/1/3/9 = 42, weighted mean 3.857), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the eight most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-08 | Cabinet Dentaire Lumière | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count (previously unknown — the headless map method never returns it), the histogram itself (90/3/3/2/14 = 112, weighted mean 4.366), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the eight most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-08 | Cabinet Dentaire Massena | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count (previously unknown — the headless map method never returns it), the histogram itself (63/1/0/0/3 = 67, weighted mean 4.806), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the eight most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-08 | Cabinet Dentaire MC2L | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count (previously unknown — the headless map method never returns it), the histogram itself (51/2/2/0/7 = 62, weighted mean 4.452), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the eight most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-08 | Cabinet Dentaire Pierre de Fermat | Browser pass (phase I): the search for a Google Business Profile was repeated in a real browser in five query forms and the absence is now confirmed rather than inferred; the building geocode for the registered address was recorded, and the opening week was read from the clinic’s own rendered contact page. |
| 2026-09-08 | Cabinet des Drs Damiani et Richelme | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count (previously unknown — the headless map method never returns it), the histogram itself (23/3/0/0/4 = 30, weighted mean 4.367), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the eight most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-08 | Cabinet Maupassant | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count (previously unknown — the headless map method never returns it), the histogram itself (126/1/0/1/4 = 132, weighted mean 4.848), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the eight most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-08 | Centre de Santé Dentaire Clinadent Marseille Saint-Pierre (La Timone) | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count, the histogram itself (633/44/10/6/74 = 767, weighted mean 4.507), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the eight most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-08 | Centre Dentaire Lyon Frères Lumière (Docali) | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count (previously unknown — the headless map method never returns it), the histogram itself (903/69/11/5/107 = 1095, weighted mean 4.512), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the eight most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-08 | Centre Dentaire Toulouse Gare Bayard | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count (previously unknown — the headless map method never returns it), the histogram itself (132/1/4/0/29 = 166, weighted mean 4.247), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the eight most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-08 | Dentego Centre Dentaire Marseille République | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count (previously unknown — the headless map method never returns it), the histogram itself (419/15/1/1/27 = 463, weighted mean 4.723), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the eight most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-08 | Dentylis — Centre Dentaire et Ophtalmologie des Terreaux | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count (previously unknown — the headless map method never returns it), the histogram itself (990/127/8/12/158 = 1295, weighted mean 4.373), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the eight most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-08 | Dr Hans Dindoyal | Reputation measured live on 2026-09-08 by the wave-5 phase-I browser pass (agent I-1), which opened this clinic’s Google Maps place page in a real browser on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. This card enters the country directory as a twin and carries no entry in data/research/*.json, so import-research.js never touched it and respondsToReviews, recurringComplaints and suspiciousReviewPatterns had never been assessed at all. Written now: googleRating 4.6 → 4.6 (unchanged, re-verified); googleReviewCount 59 → 59 (histogram 52/0/1/0/6 = 59, weighted mean 4.559); reviewRecency "within_year" → within_3_months; respondsToReviews null → true; recurringComplaints null → false; suspiciousReviewPatterns null → false. The histogram sums to the place-page header count exactly and its weighted mean reproduces the published rating to one decimal. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. The country twin was re-synchronised from this card in the same step; the two copies are identical except for the twin’s city key. |
| 2026-09-08 | Dr Olivier Vallet | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count (previously unknown — the headless map method never returns it), the histogram itself (38/0/0/0/4 = 42, weighted mean 4.619), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the eight most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-08 | Dr Phoebe Kamioner | Reputation measured live on 2026-09-08 by the wave-5 phase-I browser pass (agent I-1), which opened this clinic’s Google Maps place page in a real browser on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. This card enters the country directory as a twin and carries no entry in data/research/*.json, so import-research.js never touched it and respondsToReviews, recurringComplaints and suspiciousReviewPatterns had never been assessed at all. Written now: googleRating 4.4 → 4.4 (unchanged, re-verified); googleReviewCount 111 → 109 (histogram 92/0/1/3/13 = 109, weighted mean 4.422); reviewRecency "older" → within_3_months; respondsToReviews null → true; recurringComplaints null → false; suspiciousReviewPatterns null → false; convenientHours null → true. The histogram sums to the place-page header count exactly and its weighted mean reproduces the published rating to one decimal. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. The country twin was re-synchronised from this card in the same step; the two copies are identical except for the twin’s city key. |
| 2026-09-08 | Le Studio Dentaire | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count, the histogram itself (217/2/0/0/8 = 227, weighted mean 4.850), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the eight most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-08 | Pôle Santé ASC | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count (previously unknown — the headless map method never returns it), the histogram itself (11/0/0/0/4 = 15, weighted mean 3.933), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the eight most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-08 | The Madeleine Dental Practice | Reputation measured live on 2026-09-08 by the wave-5 phase-I browser pass (agent I-1), which opened this clinic’s Google Maps place page in a real browser on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. This card enters the country directory as a twin and carries no entry in data/research/*.json, so import-research.js never touched it and respondsToReviews, recurringComplaints and suspiciousReviewPatterns had never been assessed at all. Written now: googleRating 4.8 → 4.8 (unchanged, re-verified); googleReviewCount 282 → 283 (histogram 266/2/2/4/9 = 283, weighted mean 4.809); reviewRecency within_year (unchanged, now proved); respondsToReviews null → true; recurringComplaints null → false; suspiciousReviewPatterns null → false. The histogram sums to the place-page header count exactly and its weighted mean reproduces the published rating to one decimal. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. The country twin was re-synchronised from this card in the same step; the two copies are identical except for the twin’s city key. |
| 2026-09-08 | Vermillion Dentaire | Browser pass (phase I): the clinic’s Google Maps place page was opened in a real browser and read on both its Reviews and Overview tabs. Recorded from it: the rating re-verified against the star histogram, the review count (previously unknown — the headless map method never returns it), the histogram itself (22/0/0/0/0 = 22, weighted mean 5.000), review recency, the owner-reply state, the complaint reading and the manipulation reading from the eight most-relevant reviews, the lead owner photograph and the full published opening week. Fields this pass did not measure are untouched. |
| 2026-09-07 | Arenas Dentistes | Initial research pass. Discovered via SearXNG ('dentiste Nice'), also surfaced by the wave-5 AV pass (dental implants Nice France). Own site read live (rich named team). Google Maps headless probe resolved the exact POI. ONCD confirmed the founding dentist's RPPS on Promenade des Anglais, consistent with the practice's Nice-Ouest location. The site's own embedded review-summary widget claims 208 reviews; recorded as informational third-party-generated prose, not used as the reputation-block figure. |
| 2026-09-07 | Arenas Dentistes | Adversarial verification pass (D-france). The card's address was a district name; the clinic publishes its street address on every page (455 Promenade des Anglais, Immeuble Nice Premier) and nine ONCD register rows confirm it — corrected. The clinic's own team page names a field for each dentist, so specializationsListed becomes true, and all eight remaining dentists were matched in ONCD at that address (two of them carrying the statutory ODF speciality). Its dedicated 'Honoraires' page was read: no figures, so pricesPublished is a checked false. The en-US hreflang target arenas-dentistes.com was opened and confirmed to be a real English site. |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet 47VH | Initial research pass. Surfaced by the wave-5 AV pass (dental implants Nice France). Own bilingual site read live, with detailed named-doctor CVs. Google Maps headless probe resolved the exact POI (address/phone/geo) but carried no numeric rating. ONCD confirmed both named doctors' RPPS at the exact clinic address. |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet 47VH | Adversarial verification pass (D-france). The Google rating the research pass reported as absent is published: 5.0, read live on the same place id via a phone query. The clinic's own fee page and team page were read for the first time: seven price fields resolved from a fifteen-line published tariff, hasXray confirmed from the same table, and three further dentists (Simbille, Ballarati, Abram) named by the clinic and all matched in ONCD at the exact address. |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet Dentaire d'Ainay | Initial research pass. Discovered via SearXNG ('dentiste Lyon'). Own site read live (rich schema.org data), Google Maps headless probe resolved a real POI match, ONCD annuaire confirmed the lead dentist's RPPS at the exact clinic address. Five canonical aiVisibility queries filled from the wave-5 AV pass; emergency and expats null due to Lyon SERP namesake pollution. |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet Dentaire d'Ainay | Adversarial verification pass (D-france). Google place data re-read live under an independent query form — rating 4.4 and geo reproduced exactly. ONCD checked for all nine named dentists: six matched at the exact clinic address, one (Dr Bonnefis) matched at a different registry address (disclosed), one (Dr Abouchar) returned zero rows nationally and is recorded as licenseNotFound. The clinic's own /nos-tarifs/ page was read for the first time: a standing fee table exists (as an image), so pricesPublished is true and the per-service figures go to the browser worklist. |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet Dentaire Dr Charbit & Associés | Initial research pass. Surfaced by the wave-5 AV pass (dental implants Nice France). Own site read live. The plain-name Google Maps headless query returned only a city-centroid fallback; retried successfully with the site's own phone number, which resolved the exact business (address, geo) but with no rating figure present. ONCD confirmed Dr Charbit's RPPS at the exact clinic address. |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet Dentaire Dr Charbit & Associés | Adversarial verification pass (D-france). The rating and review count the research pass reported as absent are published on the same Google place: 5.0 from 45 reviews, read live by phone query. Dr Clémence Allain matched in the ONCD annuaire at the exact clinic address, so both named dentists now carry licence numbers. |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet dentaire du Dr Mailhes et Dr Sabatie | Initial research pass. Surfaced by the wave-5 AV pass (English speaking dentist Toulouse). Own site read live. Google Maps headless probe resolved the exact POI. ONCD confirmed both named doctors' RPPS numbers at the exact clinic address. |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet Dentaire Lumière | Initial research pass. Discovered via SearXNG ('dentiste Lyon'). Own site read live, Google Maps headless probe resolved a real POI match (rating, address, geo), ONCD annuaire confirmed Dr Berdougo's RPPS at the exact clinic address; Dr de Valbray searched under two name variants and not found in the register (licenseNotFound, no penalty). Five canonical aiVisibility queries filled from the wave-5 AV pass (scratch/wave5/aivis/france.json); emergency and expats are null because the Lyon SERP is dominated by the South Lyon, Michigan namesake (per wave-5 rule, not a false). |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet Dentaire Lumière | Adversarial verification pass (D-france). Google place data re-read live under two independent query forms — rating 4.4 and geo reproduced exactly. ONCD re-searched: Dr Roch de Valbray IS on the register under the compound surname CORMAILLE DE VALBRAY (RPPS 10003531307, exact clinic address), so the research pass's licenseNotFound was a false negative and has been withdrawn; six further associates matched at the exact clinic address and one (Dr Maud Caba) at a different registry address, all disclosed. Three aiVisibility fields raised to true under the wave-5 name-in-result rule. A second Google place at the same address (the Dr de Valbray practitioner listing, 4.8/182) is recorded in the rating note and deliberately not used. |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet Dentaire Massena | Initial research pass. Discovered via SearXNG ('dentiste Nice'). Own site read live. The plain-name Google Maps headless query returned only a city-centroid fallback; retried successfully with the site's own phone number, which resolved the exact business (rating, address, geo). ONCD confirmed Dr Melloul's RPPS at the exact clinic address. |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet Dentaire Massena | Adversarial verification pass (D-france). A fifth dentist the clinic publishes on its own team page (Dr Benoît Brehinier) was missing from the card and has been added; the only national ONCD match on that surname is at a Réunion address, so it is recorded as a namesake and the number is not attributed. Three of the four remaining dentists matched in ONCD, two at the exact clinic address. The clinic's own 'Honoraires' page was read: no figures, so pricesPublished is a checked false. Google rating 4.8 and geo reproduced under an independent query form. |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet Dentaire MC2L | Initial research pass. Surfaced by the wave-5 AV pass (dental implants Marseille). Own site read live. Google Maps headless probe resolved the exact POI (rating, address, geo). No individual dentist named on the pages read, so licensing.doctors stays empty and clinicLicense null rather than guessed. |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet Dentaire MC2L | Adversarial verification pass (D-france). The clinic's own dedicated team page was read for the first time: it names four practising dentists with their orientations, so dentistNamesListed and specializationsListed move from unchecked to true and licensing.doctors goes from empty to four ONCD-matched entries (each with its registry address disclosed, since none is filed at this street). Google rating 4.5 and geo reproduced under an independent query form; the site's own AggregateRating of 4.8/8 is recorded as self-published and not used. |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet Dentaire Pierre de Fermat | Initial research pass. Surfaced by the wave-5 AV pass (emergency dentist Toulouse) and independently by SearXNG ('cabinet dentaire Toulouse'). Own site read live (rich schema.org data, ten named dentists). Google Maps headless probe failed to resolve a specific POI across four query variants (name, two phone formats, full address) — geo/rating/googleMapsUrl left null and queued to browser worklist rather than guessed. ONCD independently confirmed the lead-named dentist's RPPS at the exact clinic address, which is why the card is kept despite the unresolved Maps pin (site + ONCD + Doctolib = the required 2+ independent sources). |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet Dentaire Pierre de Fermat | Adversarial verification pass (D-france). aiMention_implants was a false negative: the clinic's own domain is at rank 6 of the AV pass's 'dental implants Toulouse' results — corrected to true. Eight of the ten named dentists matched in the ONCD annuaire at the exact clinic address (nine rows in total with Dr Sekkat), which is unusually strong independent confirmation of a practice whose Google place still cannot be resolved. The investigative sentence about Dr Badoures's Paris registry address was moved out of the licence value into the doctor note. Three further Maps query variants were tried and all failed, so the unresolved pin is confirmed, not assumed. |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet des Drs Damiani et Richelme | Initial research pass. Surfaced by the wave-5 AV pass (dental implants Marseille). Own site read live, including its own AggregateRating/review block (recorded as clinic-published, not substituted for a live Google figure). Google Maps headless probe resolved the exact POI. ONCD confirmed both named doctors' RPPS numbers; Dr Damiani's address matches exactly, Dr Richelme's registry entry carries mode d'exercice 'Autre' with no address to cross-check. |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet des Drs Damiani et Richelme | Adversarial verification pass (D-france). Google rating 4.4 and geo reproduced under an independent query form (3 m from the card pin); both RPPS numbers re-confirmed live against the ONCD annuaire. The investigative sentence about Dr Richelme's registry row was moved out of the licence value into the doctor note, so the licence column carries the number only. The gap between the clinic's self-published AggregateRating (4.94/84) and the live Google figure (4.4) is disclosed in the structured-data note. |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet Maupassant | Initial research pass. Surfaced by the wave-5 AV pass (dental implants Marseille). Own site read live including its dedicated team page, which confirms no individual dentist is named by the clinic itself. Google Maps headless probe resolved the exact POI (rating, address, geo); note the site's own listed phone (+33 4 69 00 14 78) differs from the number Google Maps shows for the same address (+33 4 91 77 60 44) — both recorded, discrepancy noted for the gate. |
| 2026-09-07 | Cabinet Maupassant | Adversarial verification pass (D-france). The Google place attribution was confirmed from the strongest possible source — the clinic's own maps.app.goo.gl link in its site footer resolves to exactly the place id and pin on the card. Rating 4.8 reproduced under a second query form. The phone discrepancy between the site and the Google listing is now recorded in the contacts note. Five service/AI fields were filled from the clinic's own treatment pages and its own aesthetic-dentistry subdomain. |
| 2026-09-07 | Centre de Santé Dentaire Clinadent Marseille Saint-Pierre (La Timone) | Initial research pass. Discovered via SearXNG ('centre dentaire Marseille'), also surfaced independently by the wave-5 AV pass under its own domain. Own landing-page site read live. Google Maps headless probe needed a brand-name retry (the plain address query returned only a city-centroid fallback) and resolved the exact POI, revealing the live corporate domain is now clinadent.fr. FINESS live lookup matched this exact health centre by denomination and address — six Clinadent centres exist in Marseille under one legal entity (ASSOCIATION CLINADENT); only this Saint-Pierre/La Timone one is attributed to this card. |
| 2026-09-07 | Centre de Santé Dentaire Clinadent Marseille Saint-Pierre (La Timone) | Adversarial verification pass (D-france). The review count the research pass reported as unavailable was in fact in the same live Google place data: 767 reviews at 4.5. The centre's own dedicated team page was read: it names no individual dentist, so dentistNamesListed becomes a checked false rather than an unchecked null, and it independently confirms the ARS PACA authorisation behind the FINESS record. Branch-specific Facebook and group social profiles recorded from the centre's own site. FINESS record re-queried live and reproduced exactly. |
| 2026-09-07 | Centre Dentaire Lyon Frères Lumière (Docali) | Initial research pass. Discovered via SearXNG ('dentiste Lyon'). Own site read live (health-centre branch, no named dentist published). Google Maps headless probe resolved the exact POI. FINESS lookup under 'LUMIERE'/'DOCALI' in Rhône found a same-avenue, different-address homonym rather than this clinic — recorded honestly as unmatched (null) rather than risk a false institutional-licence attribution. |
| 2026-09-07 | Centre Dentaire Lyon Frères Lumière (Docali) | Adversarial verification pass (D-france). The institutional licence the research pass could not attribute has been found: FINESS files this centre as 'CENTRE DE SANTE DENTASMILE LYON 8' (690046289) at the card's exact address under ASSOCIATION DENTASMILE, whose SIREN matches the one the clinic publishes in its own legal notice; the similarly-named centre at 42 Avenue des Frères Lumière is confirmed to be a different establishment. The clinic's own team page and fee page were read for the first time, turning two unchecked nulls into checked values, and three service fields were filled from its own treatment pages. |
| 2026-09-07 | Centre Dentaire Toulouse Gare Bayard | Initial research pass. Discovered via SearXNG ('cabinet dentaire Toulouse'), also surfaced independently by the wave-5 AV pass on three of its four queries. Own site read live (health-centre branch, no named dentist published). Google Maps headless probe resolved the exact POI. FINESS live lookup matched this exact health centre by denomination and exact address, correctly distinguishing it from a same-department, differently-addressed namesake association. |
| 2026-09-07 | Centre Dentaire Toulouse Gare Bayard | Adversarial verification pass (D-france). Google rating 4.2, address and geo reproduced under an independent query form; FINESS record re-queried live and reproduced exactly, including the exclusion of the 19 Rue Bayard namesake. The clinic's own dedicated team page was read, upgrading dentistNamesListed from a homepage-only false to a team-page-verified false. Google and the site's own title show the operator brand as 'Place Dentaire', recorded in the summary. |
| 2026-09-07 | Dentego Centre Dentaire Marseille République | Initial research pass. Discovered via Google Maps headless probe after the SearXNG discovery pass surfaced the Dentego network. dentego.fr could not be reached from this network (connection timeout, retried on both the branch page and the site root) — existence, address, phone, geo and rating are confirmed live from the Google Maps listing itself, but no page body could be read this pass, so hasWebsite/dentistNamesListed/serviceListPublished/englishVersion/hasStructuredData are honestly null rather than guessed. Queued to browser worklist for a body read. |
| 2026-09-07 | Dentego Centre Dentaire Marseille République | Adversarial verification pass (D-france). The institutional licence is now attributed: FINESS files this centre under the generic denomination « CENTRE DE SANTE DENTAIRE MARSEILLE » (130052707) at the card's exact address — invisible to a search on the Dentego trade name, which is why the research pass came up empty. The unreachability of dentego.fr was independently reproduced with a second client, so the website-derived nulls remain honest rather than provisional. Google rating 4.7, address and geo reproduced under an independent query form. |
| 2026-09-07 | Dentylis — Centre Dentaire et Ophtalmologie des Terreaux | Initial research pass. Discovered via SearXNG ('dentiste Lyon'). Own site read live (a "centre de santé" health-centre branch of the Dentylis network, no named dentist published). Google Maps headless probe resolved the exact POI (address/phone/geo) but carried no numeric rating. FINESS live lookup matched this health centre by denomination and exact address — the correct institutional register for a French centre de santé, distinct from ONCD which covers individual practitioners. |
| 2026-09-07 | Dentylis — Centre Dentaire et Ophtalmologie des Terreaux | Adversarial verification pass (D-france). The Google rating the research pass reported as absent is in fact published: 4.4, read live under two independent query forms on the same place id. FINESS record reproduced exactly. The network's own pricing page was read: it publishes no figures, so pricesPublished is a checked false rather than an unchecked null. The absence of a branch team page was re-confirmed from the branch page's own link inventory. |
| 2026-09-07 | Dr Olivier Vallet | Initial research pass. Surfaced by the wave-5 AV pass (dental implants Toulouse). Own site read live. Google Maps headless probe resolved the exact POI. ONCD confirmed the dentist's RPPS at the exact clinic address. |
| 2026-09-07 | Le Studio Dentaire | Initial research pass. Surfaced directly by the wave-5 AV pass (appears in both 'best dentist Lyon France' and 'dental implants Lyon France'). Own English-language site read live. The plain-name Google Maps headless query returned only a city-centroid fallback (no POI); retried successfully with the site's own phone number, which resolved the exact business (rating 4.9, address). ONCD confirmed Dr Touati's RPPS at the exact address. |
| 2026-09-07 | Le Studio Dentaire | Adversarial verification pass (D-france). Google place re-read live by phone query: rating 4.9 confirmed and the review count (227) recovered, which the research pass had reported as not exposed. The clinic's own team page and price list were read for the first time: a third dentist (Dr Thibault Nicollet) is published by the clinic and matched in ONCD at the exact address, Dr Romane Touati Chebance's RPPS was matched, and seven price fields were resolved from the clinic's published tariff. |
| 2026-09-07 | Methodology v1.4.0 | Narrowed the "Opaque or bait pricing" red flag to what its published definition describes. Until now the flag was applied automatically to every clinic that does not publish a price list — a harsher statement than the evidence supports, since the catalogue defines the flag as complaints about final bills materially exceeding quoted prices, or advertised prices that are not honoured. Not publishing prices is already scored: it costs the clinic points in the price transparency category, and it is not, on its own, evidence of bait pricing. The automatic rule is removed, so the flag and its 2-point penalty come off about 1,300 clinic pages across the index; no clinic gains a flag, and no weight, severity or other scoring rule changed. The flag can still be recorded against a clinic by hand with cited sources, and about 210 clinics carry such an entry today; we are reviewing those entries in a follow-up pass, because some of them were also written for nothing more than an unpublished price list. |
| 2026-09-07 | Pôle Santé ASC | Initial research pass. Surfaced by the wave-5 AV pass (dental implants Toulouse). Own site read live (5 named dentists). The plain-name Google Maps headless query returned only a city-centroid fallback; retried successfully with the site's own phone number, which resolved the exact business. ONCD confirmed the lead-named doctor's RPPS at the exact clinic address; the other four named doctors are recorded with license null (not yet checked). |
| 2026-09-07 | Pôle Santé ASC | Adversarial verification pass (D-france). clearContacts was a self-contradicting false — the research note itself recorded that the clinic publishes its phone number in structured data — and the live page in fact carries two tel: links plus the number in plain text; corrected to true. All four remaining named dentists matched in the ONCD annuaire at the exact clinic address, so the card now carries five licence numbers instead of one. Google rating 3.9 and geo reproduced under an independent query form. |
| 2026-09-07 | Vermillion Dentaire | Initial research pass. Surfaced by the wave-5 AV pass (the five canonical city queries). Own site is a Wix single-page app: the static HTML delivered to a non-JS client carries only the phone number and a trilingual-reception claim, not staff names or address text — those fields are left null/browser-worklist rather than guessed. Google Maps headless probe resolved the exact POI independently (address, phone match, rating, geo). |
| 2026-09-07 | Vermillion Dentaire | Adversarial verification pass (D-france). The research pass concluded from the /en page that the Wix site rendered nothing without JavaScript; the French pages are in fact server-rendered, and reading them recovered the practice's two named dentists (both matched in ONCD at the exact clinic address), its published treatment list, its schema.org block and its street address. Six criteria moved from unchecked to verified and the card gained a doctor roster. Google rating 5.0, address and geo reproduced under an independent query form. |
| 2026-09-03 | Methodology v1.3.1 | Clarified that the publication criteria refer to the clinic’s own channels: a service list, the names of the dentists and a price list count when the clinic itself publishes them (its website, its social profiles or its own Google Business profile) — registers, directories and review sites do not, and a time-limited promotional offer is not a price list. Added a third state for a dentist’s licence, "checked, not found in the public register": a dentist we searched for in the national register and did not find is now recorded as checked-but-unverified with the date of the check, instead of being shown either as "not checked yet" or as the "not published" red flag. Neither change alters any weight or penalty; the red-flag rule still fires only on a verified negative. Also corrected the wording of the penalty note under the ranking table, which rendered as "20−" in right-to-left dictionaries. |
| 2026-08-25 | 62LTM / Dr Karim Dada | Re-verification 2026-08-25: the original '62LTM' listing at the on-file address (Boulevard de la Tour-Maubourg, 75007 Paris, same phone) shows 'Permanently closed' on Google Maps. Dr. Karim Dada now practices at a new address, 8 Rue Guy de Maupassant, 75116 Paris, with a new practice website (dr-dada-karim.chirurgiens-dentistes.fr); phone unchanged (+33 1 42 88 40 81); the original leadingimplantcenters.com profile page is still live as a bio/profile page. Updated address and website fields to the new location. Captured Google rating 5.0 (70 reviews), geo coordinates and Maps URL at the new address. Sedation research: no anaesthesia/sedation information found on the current practice site (academic publications by Dr. Dada reference general anaesthesia/MEOPA sedation in implant-surgery literature generally, but this was not confirmed as offered directly by his own clinic, so left unset). |
| 2026-08-25 | 62LTM / Dr Karim Dada | License verification 2026-08-25 against ONCD annuaire: both named doctors (Karim Dada, Dorothee Louis-Olszewski) found with matching RPPS numbers, corroborated by older-format Ordre numbers published on the clinic's own mentions-legales page; registry still shows their former Tour-Maubourg address rather than the current Rue Guy de Maupassant location. FINESS not applicable (liberal cabinet, not a centre de sante); clinic's own site shows only a commercial SIRET/RCS. |
| 2026-08-25 | Dr Hans Dindoyal | Re-verification 2026-08-25: website (live, 2026 copyright) and Instagram (posts as recent as April 2026) both active; address/phone unchanged. However Google Maps currently flags the profile 'Temporarily closed' (not 'Permanently closed') — likely a seasonal August closure given the otherwise active site/social presence and an owner review-response dated 3 months ago; recommend re-checking after August. Google rating changed 4.5/28 to current 4.6/59; captured geo coordinates and Maps URL. Sedation research: site's pre-op instructions and wisdom-tooth page state extraction is done 'sous anesthésie locale ou générale' — general anaesthesia is documented as offered. |
| 2026-08-25 | Dr Hans Dindoyal | Recorded sedation / general anaesthesia availability (informational): documented as available. Wisdom-tooth extraction documented as done under local or general anaesthesia |
| 2026-08-25 | Dr Hans Dindoyal | License verification 2026-08-25 against ONCD annuaire: Dr Hans Dindoyal found, RPPS 10100252518, Liberal, address matches exactly. FINESS not applicable (solo liberal cabinet). |
| 2026-08-25 | Dr Phoebe Kamioner | Re-verification 2026-08-25: confirmed website live, address, phone unchanged, clinic open. Newly captured Google rating 4.4 (111 reviews), geo coordinates and Maps URL (previously unset). Sedation research: site's extraction page states wisdom-tooth extraction 'peut être réalisée sous anesthésie locale ou générale en fonction des cas' — general anaesthesia documented as an option; standard extractions are local-anaesthesia only. |
| 2026-08-25 | Dr Phoebe Kamioner | Recorded sedation / general anaesthesia availability (informational): documented as available. Wisdom-tooth extraction documented as available under local or general anaesthesia depending on case difficulty; standard extractions are local-only |
| 2026-08-25 | Dr Phoebe Kamioner | License verification 2026-08-25 against ONCD annuaire: Dr Phoebe Kamioner found, RPPS 10107326166, Liberal, address matches exactly. FINESS not applicable (liberal cabinet). |
| 2026-08-25 | Methodology v1.3.0 | Corrected how the two licensing red flags are applied ("Clinic operating licence not published" and "Dentists / their licences not listed"). Previously they were applied whenever licensing data was absent from our records, which treated unchecked data as a negative finding — contrary to the methodology's own rule that unverified data is a fact about our coverage, not about the clinic. Both flags now apply only where we have verified that the information is not published. Manual licensing flags that rested on unverified data were removed from the affected clinics. No other scoring rules changed; most scores rise because the incorrect penalty is removed. |
| 2026-08-25 | The Madeleine Dental Practice | Re-verification 2026-08-25: website live at cabinet-dentaire-madeleine.com, address/phone unchanged, clinic open. This entity is now the merged practice absorbing 'La Smile Clinic' (smile-clinic.fr permanently redirects here; the site itself says 'formerly Smile Clinic Paris'). Newly captured Google rating 4.8 (282 reviews), geo coordinates and Maps URL. Sedation research: site states wisdom-tooth extraction is done under local anaesthesia only — no GA/deep sedation documented. |
| 2026-08-25 | The Madeleine Dental Practice | Recorded sedation / general anaesthesia availability (informational): not documented in public sources. Wisdom-tooth extraction documented as done under local anaesthesia only; no GA/deep sedation mentioned |
| 2026-08-25 | The Madeleine Dental Practice | License verification 2026-08-25 against ONCD annuaire: all 12 named doctors found with matching RPPS numbers; 11 of 12 match the clinic address exactly, one (Dr Joseph Dardas) matches on name+specialty but the registry lists a different Paris address (44 Bd de Reuilly, 75012) -- flagged for human review rather than marked false. FINESS clinic-establishment search could not be completed (SPA requires browser session, unavailable this session); mentions-legales shows only a commercial RCS number for SELARL MONTAIGNE TREMOILLE. |
| 2026-08-23 | Methodology v1.2.0 | Added an informational "Sedation & general anaesthesia" availability field to every clinic and a new "Sleep Dentistry (Sedation / GA)" list, for patients who cannot tolerate — or would rather not be awake for — treatment. This field is informational and does not change any transparency score. |
| 2026-07-08 | 62LTM / Dr Karim Dada | Initial data collection. |
| 2026-07-08 | Dr Hans Dindoyal | Initial data collection. |
| 2026-07-08 | Dr Phoebe Kamioner | Initial data collection. |
| 2026-07-08 | Methodology v1.1.0 | Added licensing transparency: clinics are now penalised when they do not publish their operating licence, or do not list their dentists together with their professional licence numbers. Each clinic page now shows a Licensing & Credentials section. |
| 2026-07-08 | The Madeleine Dental Practice | Initial data collection. |
| 2026-07-03 | Methodology v1.0.0 | Initial public methodology. |